Jones, D. C., Campbell, M. M., & Acheson, K. (2019). Intercultural learning in semester-long study abroad: A comparative analysis of the effectiveness of one-on-one versus group-mentored interventions. Journal on Excellence in College Teaching, 30(4), 7-35
The study investigated the impact of mentoring on a semester-long study abroad initiative. The study was conducted at a midwestern university. The data was collected from 376 undergraduate students who participated in a semester-long study abroad initiative in the Fall and Spring of 2017 and 2018. The study used a quasi-experimental design with two treatment groups and one control group. Students in all three groups completed the pre and post-IDI assessment and participated in a study abroad. The Treatment group 1 (INDVI) students received individual mentoring while on a study abroad trip. Also, pre-departure, they were engaged in multiple activities that helped them develop cultural awareness and sensitivity. Treatment group 2 (GROUP) received group mentoring during their study abroad and engaged in in-person and online activities before departure. The students from the control group did not receive any intervention (mentoring) in their study abroad. The study used ANOVA to identify statistical significance among the three groups.
Also, the threshold p-value for the study was 0.1. The results indicated a large statistically significant difference in the DO scores of the control group and Treatment group 1 (individually mentored, referred to as INDVI). There was also a marginal statistically significant difference between the DO scores of the control group vs. Treatment group 2 (group mentored, referred to as GROUP) and Treatment group 1 versus Treatment group 2. The analysis also revealed that for the INDVI, 57% of students progressed one or more orientations, and 5.6% regressed. For GROUP Mentoring, 52.7% of students progressed, and 13.7% regressed. Also, in INDVI, 57.8% of students demonstrated meaningful growth, and in the case of GROUP mentoring, 52.6% of students demonstrated meaningful growth. Overall the study demonstrated the effectiveness of mentoring students during the semester-long study abroad program using a robust experimental design. The empirical study also provided evidence on how institutions can help students develop intercultural skills and identified measures to evaluate the development using IDI.
2019
Quantitative
International Education
2016-2020